Brewster's New Buffalo Menu (Update 2025)
Brewster's New Buffalo is a charming restaurant located in New Buffalo, MI, offering a delightful blend of Italian cuisine, pizza, and breakfast/brunch options. With a wide array of amenities like outdoor seating, full bar, and wheelchair accessibility, Brewster's caters to diverse customer needs. Customers rave about the consistently excellent food and welcoming ambiance, making it a must-visit spot in the area. Reviewers highlight the friendly service, generous portion sizes, and delicious dishes such as the Betty White pizza and bruschetta. The option for dinner for two provides great value and allows for a memorable dining experience with loved ones. Whether you're looking for a casual meal or a special celebration, Brewster's New Buffalo delivers on both taste and atmosphere.
OTHER BEVOTHER BEV
Acqua Panna Still Water
Arnold Palmer
Flavored Pelligrino
blood orange or limonata
Fresh Squeezed OJ
Iced Tea
Italian Soda
Juices
orange, cranberry, or apple
Kids Bev
Large Milk
Lavender Lemonade
Lemonade
Raspberry Lemonade
San Pellegrino
italian natural mineral water oz
Small Milk
Soda
coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, lemonade, ginger ale, soda water, tonic water, iced tea
Tonic
Topo Chico
Strawberry Lemonade
Dram Gingergrass
Large AquaPanna
Ginger Beer
Avocado Toast
spiced avocado mousse + spinach + bruschetta topped w/ two eggs over-easy
Berry Pancakes
stack of pancakes w/ our homemade berry sauce
Biscuits + Gravy
biscuits + sausage gravy finished w/ scallions
Breakfast BLT
smoked bacon + lettuce + roma tomatoes w/ two over easy eggs garlic aioli on sun dried tomato focaccia
Eggs In Purgatory
italian sausage + sweet peppers in spicy marinara baked w/ asiago cheese + topped w/ two over-easy eggs + a biscuit
Frittata Of The Day
ask your server for todays selection served w/ potatoes + a biscuit ' no substitutions
Hippie Hash
onion + roasted garlic + roasted red peppers : mushroom + spinach + potatoes + fresh herbs finished w/ roasted garlic oil + served w/ a side of toast
Mary's Mess
"the mess" + a brewster's bloody mary
Mascarpone - Stuffed French Toast
brioche dipped in custard + topped w/ our homemade berry sauce + powdered sugar
Pancakes
stack of served w/ pure maple syrup
Regular French Toast
The Mess
our house specialty scramble w/ cheddar cheese + bacon + onion + roasted red peppers + potatoes + eggs + roasted garlic + sausage w/ a biscuit no substitutions
The Old Standby
two eggs to order + potatoes + choice of bacon or sausage + a biscuit
Breakfast Burrito
Bourbon Butter Banana
Feature
BREAKFAST ENTREESBREAKFAST ENTREES
A LA CARTEA LA CARTE
Bacon
two strips
( ) Eggs
two cooked to order
Sausage
two pieces
Biscuit
served w/ dara's homemade jam
SD Of Hippie Hash
onion + roasted garlic + roasted red peppers + mushroom + spinach + potatoes + fresh herbs finished w/ roasted garlic oil +
SD Potatoes
Side Of Gravy
Single Pancake
Toast W Jam
() EGG
Kids Berry Pancakes
served w/ our homemade berry sauce
Kids Egg Breakfast
two eggs scrambled w/ cheddar cheese + a biscuit
Kids Pancakes
served w/ maple syrup
Kids French Toast
KIDS BREAKFASTKIDS BREAKFAST
SOURDOUGH PIES SOURDOUGH PIES
Pizza Time
America
Betty White
Freshy
New Yorker
fontina + provolone + mozzarella + pizza sauce + finished w /shaved pecorino + dry oregano + crushed chilis + garlic oil
Sweet + Spicy
cup n' char pepperoni + calabrian chili's + deli pepperoni + fresh mozzarella + crushed tomato base + basil drizzled w/ spicy honey + reggiano SF
" Blackberry
lemon ricotta, shaved yellow onion, fresh mint and prosciutto topped with blackberry gastrique
Pizza Special
Bianco
roasted garlic + spinach + ricotta + sausage + fontina + reggiano + e.v.o.o. base
Cali Pie
Fungi
garlic, roasted mushroom, sausage, fresh oregano and ricotta on an evoo base topped with truffle oil
Marg Pie
Quattro Formaggi
aged gorgonzola + house cheese + provolone + mozzarella + pesto base
" Popper
THIN CRUST SPECIAL PIES THIN CRUST SPECIAL PIES
" SD CRUST SPECIAL PIES" SD CRUST SPECIAL PIES
" Cali
" Margherita
" Quattro Formaggi
Funghi
Bianco
Sweet & Spicy
New Yorker
Betty White
BYO Pizza
WITH ANY TWO REGULAR TOPPINGS {includes pizza cheese} choose your crust/pick a base/regular toppings . each/special toppings . each
" Pizza
with any two toppings (thin crust only)
BYO ", PizzaBYO ", Pizza
Classic CoffeesClassic Coffees
Hot Tea
japanese sencha green tea, english breakfast tea, raspberry decaf tea, cinnamon spice black tea, herbal decaf ceylon black tea, + earl grey
Med Coffee
Mocha
Cappuccino
Espresso
Latte
BOLOGNESE
Cacio E Pepe
black pepper + parmesan + linguini + scarpetta/add chicken / add shrimp / gluten free pasta
Chicken Alfredo
baby spinach + roasted red peppers + parmesan cream sauce tossed w/ pappardelle finished w/ reggiano/add chicken / add shrimp / gluten free pasta
Meatballs
house-made marinara + ground beef and pork meatballs + long pasta/add chicken / add shrimp / gluten free pasta
Roma
tri-color cheese filled tortellini sauteed in e.v.o.o. + roma tomatoes + basil + garlic + reggiano/add chicken / add shrimp / gluten free pasta
Shrimp + Sausage
sauteed white shrimp + rope sausage + artichoke hearts + spinach + roasted red peppers + pappardelle + white wine chili flake garlic butter sauce topped w/ reggiano + pecorino/add chicken / add shrimp / gluten free pasta
Shrimp Alfredo
baby spinach + roasted red peppers + parmesan cream sauce tossed w/ pappardelle finished w/ reggiano/add chicken / add shrimp / gluten free pasta
Tikka Masala
rich tomato and butter sauce+ curry spiced chicken + lime basmati rice+ cilantro +sweet pomegranate crema
CLASSICSCLASSICS
REFRESHMENTSREFRESHMENTS
Acqua Panna Still Water
Flavored Pelligrino
blood orange or limonata
Strawberry Lemonade
Juices
orange, cranberry, or apple
Lavender Lemonade
Raspberry Lemonade
San Pellegrino
italian natural mineral water oz
Soda
coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, lemonade, ginger ale, soda water, tonic water, iced tea
Topo Chico
$Balsamic$
$Dressing$
$Gorg$
/ Chopped Salad + Soup
/ Chopped Salad Solo
/ Specialty Salad + Soup
/ Specialty Salad Solo
/ Steak Salad + Soup
/ Steak Salad Solo
Chopped Margherita
chopped lettuce + tomatoes + fresh mozzarella + olives + red onion topped w/ basil + reggiano + pine nuts + balsamic reduction
Double House
House Salad
mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan our creamy balsamic dressing
House Salad + Soup
mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan + our creamy balsamic dressing
Rustic Steak Salad
sauteed beef tips served medium rare + bed of mixed greens + roasted potatoes + mushrooms + onions + melted gorgonzola creamy tarragon dressing
Hot Soup
Hot Soup Quart
Specialty Salad
seared salmon + turkish apricots + almonds + chevre + cherry tomatoes + mixed greens + honey dijon vinaigrette
Taco Night
Wedge
SALADSSALADS
SANDWICHESSANDWICHES
Brewster's Nightclub
wood fired w/ salami + capicola + pepperoni + mozzarella + provolone + sourdough flatbread; finished w/ red onion + artisan greens + red wine vinegar
Philly Sammie
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
turkey w/ our house made basil pesto + creamy fontina cheese + roma tomatoes on hearth baked sourdough add bacon
Spicy Tuna Melt
butter toasted Texas toast+zesty tuna salad+creamy fontina and American cheese+ shrettuce+fresh dill+salt and vinegar chips
BLT
Chicken Sandwich
Double Smashburger
Bbq Rib Special
Pizza Sando
Lunch Sando
Small Triple Crown
Grande and cup-n-char pepperoni, Wisconsin brick and white cheddar cheeses on a crispy and chewy crust topped with mozzarella, basil, hot honey and crushed red tomato sauce
Deroit
spinach and artichoke dip, chicken, bacon and red onion finished with buffalo sauce and buttermilk vinaigrette
Pizza Special
SMALL SPECIAL DETROITSSMALL SPECIAL DETROITS
Specialty CoffeesSpecialty Coffees
Chai Tea Latte
Golden Latte
golden milk (turmeric infused milk), espresso, honey, + cinnamon
Hot Chocolate
home-made steamed chocolate milk
Glacier Cappuccino
Lavender Latte
lavender tea latte
Salted Caramel White Chocolate Mocha
Warm Hug
cinnamon + carmel latte
Orange Cardamom Iced Latte
Strawberry Mint Iced Matcha
Bruschetta
roma tomatoes + red onion + basil + e.v.o.o. + reggiano aged balsamic reduction w/ crostini
Charcuterie Board
lavender, raspberry, ginger rotating cured meats + artisanal cheeses w/ dried fruits nuts spreads + jams + crostini
Extra Bread
Flatbread
Hashbrown & Caviar
Ricotta + Honeycomb
house-made rosemary ricotta and honeycomb
Spinach + Artichoke Dip
served w/ rustic flatbread
Tomato Bread
Croquette
STARTERSSTARTERS
BYO SMALL DETROITSBYO SMALL DETROITS
SMALL BYO DETROIT STYLE
" Cali
" Margherita
" Quattro Formaggi
Funghi
Bianco
Sweet & Spicy
New Yorker
Betty White
" Sourdough SPECIAL PIES" Sourdough SPECIAL PIES
BYO BYO
BYO Pizza
WITH ANY TWO REGULAR TOPPINGS {includes pizza cheese} choose your crust/pick a base/regular toppings . each/special toppings . each
BOLOGNESE
Slow braised ground pork + carrot soffrito+ fresh herbs+ ricotta+ chili butter scarpetta+ pasta
Cacio E Pepe
black pepper + parmesan + pecorino + linguini + scarpetta
Chicken Alfredo
baby spinach + roasted red peppers + parmesan cream sauce tossed w/ pappardelle + reggiano
Meatballs
house-made marinara + ground beef and pork meatballs + long pasta
Roma
tri-color cheese filled tortellini sauteed in e.v.o.o. + roma tomatoes + basil + garlic + reggiano
Shrimp Alfredo
baby spinach, roasted pepper and parmesan cream sauce tossed with herb pappardelle and reggiano
SHRIMP AND SAUSAGE
sauteed white shrimp, rope sausage, artichoke heart, spinach, roasted red pepper, white wine butter garlic sauce and herb pappardelle topped with chili flake, reggiano and pecorino
Lasagna
Dinner Feature
DINNER PASTADINNER PASTA
DINNER ENTREESDINNER ENTREES
Bistecca
Halibut
Piri Chicken
fire roasted, red pepper basted airline chicken, pearl couscous, buttermilk vinaigrette and celery escabeche
Short Rib & Hummus
bbq dry rub white shrimp, jimmy red corn grits, heirloom tomato country gravy and reggiano
Single Smash
Tikka Masala
White Cioppino
horseradish veloute, blue lip mussels, salmon, shrimp, roasted red pepper, potato gnocchi and salmon roe
Chopped Margherita
chopped lettuce + tomatoes + fresh mozzarella + olives + red onion topped w/ basil + reggiano + pine nuts + balsamic reduction
Double House
Dressing
Extra Bread
Gazpacho
Hot Soup
Hot Soup Quart
House Salad
mixed greens + croutons + pecorino + parmesan our creamy balsamic dressing
Rustic Steak Salad
sauteed beef tips served medium rare + bed of mixed greens + roasted potatoes + mushrooms + onions + melted gorgonzola creamy tarragon dressing
Specialty Salad
seared salmon + turkish apricots + almonds + chevre + cherry tomatoes + mixed greens + honey dijon vinaigrette
/ Chop Solo
DINNER SALADSDINNER SALADS
KIDS PIZZAKIDS PIZZA
KIDS " BYO PIZZA
" cheese and one topping - choose your base: tomato sauce, pesto or olive oil
Kids Pasta Of The Day
chef's choice of pasta w/ your choice () sauce: marinara, olive oil, butter or cheese sauce
Kids Roma
tri-color tortellini tossed in garlic oil w/ roma tomatoes, basil & reggiano cheese $ per meatball / $ chicken / $ seafood