Consistently excellent food. Delightful outside seating when the weather permits. When You are in the area try this out. The app forces me to write more... but this is what i want 2 say

Might be bias here, because Italian is top 3 favorite foods, but this place was recommend by a friend to try whenever we had a chance to visit the closer part of Michigan. First of all, our waitress, super sweet!! Customer service does matter and she was on it!! So sad her name didn't stay with me though. We got seated by the cute fireplace, which was perfect for the chilly day. We got a bottle of wine, some starters and the Betty white pizza. We were planning on getting another Pasta dish but we were stuffed! Did not expect the artichoke dip to come with garlicky bread instead of the usual chips but we were not complaining. Would definitely return.

The service was great, the food was delicious and didn't break my bank account, but I hate when they nail you for a "convenience fee".... I would rather leave that for the server. Also, a woman at the next table was enjoying a birthday lunch with her boyfriend. I asked two different waiters if they could bring her something for her birthday, a piece of cake, a cupcake, a cookie. Crickets. If they had done those things, it would've been a five and they would've knocked it out of the park.

Nice atmosphere, friendly service. Our waiter split our bill between our party which was appreciated. Make sure to make a reservation on open table as this is a busy area. We had dinner at 9pm on a Saturday with a reservation. We didn't end up getting seated until 9:20 because it was so busy. Bread is available if you request it. Only the first round is free. We had bruschetta as an appetizer (6 pieces). There was the perfect amount of toppings and the right size bread to go with it. I would order this again! It was so tasty! I had chicken Alfredo for my dinner. The portion sizes on the pasta is ginormous. It is easily two meals. I liked the sauce and the pasta. The chicken in it was just average. The pizza that people ordered looked delicious as well as the desserts. My entire table really enjoyed their meals. We would come back!

So very nice. My family took a quick day trip to New Buffalo. They have these cute little shops in this touristy town. And we decided to break bread here. The service is so sweet. It's clean and the food is yummy. Their menu isn't crazy extensive but what they do offer, they offer deliciously. There's not a lot. We just parked within the town and took a nice, little walk.

I had a great time at Brewster's when I went last weekend with family! First, I loved the outdoor patio seating--so cute and felt like we were tucked away with no sight of the other shops/restaurants/passersby of New Buffalo. I also enjoyed the option to do the dinner for 2 which included a soup or salad each, a pizza to split, an entree to split, and a cookie each for dessert! All for I believe $58? Great deal. I do wish the entree would've been split on 2 different plates for us but NBD, we split it ourselves. Our server was perfectly nice & attentive. All in all a great experience and I'd definitely recommend! OH and the bread, oil, and shredded cheese they give you--put some salt & pepper and shredded cheese in the oil and dip away and it is *chef's kiss* delish! Xoxo, Is this thing on?

Brewster New Buffalo was a cute place. we stopped here for lunch before our trip to the beach. We were lucky enough to get parking right outside of the door, which seems like it could be a challenge with the smaller parking lot. The wait was fairly short for our party six. The table was between, cute outdoor floral decor. It appears that they had more outdoor seating than indoor seating. The trainee that was with our server, name was Taylor, and she was super sweet! my salad came with their homemade balsamic vinaigrette, which was delicious! my daughter ordered a kids pizza and absolutely loved it

I decided to check this place out with my mom for Mother's Day. It did not disappoint. They brought us a little basket of bread and the sourdough bread contained inside was very delicious! It was very soft in the center and crunchy on the outside perfection! We decided to have the two dinners (I think it was) for 59.99 It included a salad, a pasta, a pizza with two toppings, and a cookie. I'm not really a big fan of balsamic vinaigrette, but the dressing they had on the salad was delicious! If you're not a big fan of tomato, I would suggest skipping the spaghetti and meatball because it is very heavy on the tomatoes. I kind of picked mine aside, but the meatballs were very moist and tender. The pizza I added an extra two dollars for sourdough crust and it was worth it. The only downfall I can say is that I took the pizza and tried to eat it cold the next day it wasn't that great. I always judge a pizza on how good it is the next day out of the fridge. Call me, but that's my definition of a good pizza. The pizza was great hot and right out of the oven reheating it not so much. The service was very strained that day because it was so busy! But it didn't stop our server from zooming to table to table and making sure everyone had everything they needed. Our service was outstanding. As far as the ambience goes, it was a nice restaurant very crowded so it was hard to truly appreciate the beauty of the place. I would definitely come back.